Market News

Beacon and the Catskills: Where NYC Buyers' Upstate Interest Holds Steady

· 5 min read

Celebrity sightings in Beacon and the Catskills are easy to find this time of year. Whether that glamour is turning into home shopping is a harder question, and the listing data points to a more measured answer than the headlines suggest.

Here's the thing: the celebrity draw is real. Hollywood actors, reality stars, and influencers have been heading upstate for vacations, weddings, and the occasional permanent move. Olivia Wilde and Rami Malek have both stayed at a mountain lodge in Hunter. Jennifer Grey, Ali Wentworth, Olivia Rodrigo, and George Stephanopoulos traveled to the region in 2024 for the wedding of Schuyler Fox, daughter of Michael J. Fox and Tracy Pollan.

The Catskills have drawn Hollywood actors, reality stars, and influencers for vacations, weddings, and a quieter place to call home.(seen on her NY farm) (mingey/Instagram)

That same summer, YouTube star Ethan Dolan and influencer Kristina Alice picked the Catskills for their wedding. Alice later posted photos from the celebration on Instagram, giving followers a look at the setting.

Fashion has taken notice, too. Vogue editor Naomi Elizée and Anthony Blue Jr. married in a meadow in Tannersville, hosting guests for a weekend of festivities.

For Amanda Seyfried, the Catskills offered a place to put down roots. The actress purchased a 1930s farm in 2013 while looking for a retreat from Hollywood, and the property became her main residence. (mingey/Instagram)

Amanda Seyfried is the clearest example of a visit turning into a permanent address. She bought a 1930s farm in 2013 while looking for a retreat from Hollywood, and it became her main residence.

Across the Hudson, Beacon pulls people in with contemporary art, vintage shops, and a short trip from the city. Model and creator Bri Scalesse documented a visit that included Dia Beacon and some vintage shopping, an itinerary that works equally well for a day trip or a long weekend.

What a Home Costs Upstate

According to Realtor.com® data, the median asking price in Beacon was $700,000 in September. In Woodstock, a town included in the Catskills analysis, it was $968,750 in October.

Those figures are snapshots of two individual markets. The broader analysis covers all of Dutchess County, where Beacon sits, along with five Catskills counties.

Browsing tells a similar story. The Catskills accounted for 1.17% of all listing views from the New York City metro in the third quarter, up from 1.03% a year earlier. Dutchess County's share climbed from 0.53% to 0.58%, which gives the Catskills roughly twice the share of NYC-area browsing that Dutchess receives.

Main Street in Beacon, New York with Historic Brick Buildings and Fall Foliage
Between Beacon's waterfall-side boutique hotel and the Catskills' mountain lodges with private soaking tubs, the destinations offer plenty of reasons to leave the city behind for a few days. For some visitors, a weekend away becomes the inspiration for something more permanent. (Getty Images)

A Bigger Slice of a Smaller Pool

Both destinations gained share while the overall pool got smaller. NYC-metro views of Catskills listings fell about 28% year over year, and views of Dutchess County listings dropped about 31%. Across all listings, NYC-area views fell more sharply, by roughly 37%.

New York still sends the most traffic to both markets, though its grip is loosening. NYC-metro shoppers generated 37.5% of Catskills listing views, down from 42.3% a year earlier. In Dutchess County, their share slipped from 43.3% to 39.8%. Shoppers from elsewhere are filling more of the gap.

Beacon. NY
But what does it cost to buy a place in these coveted retreats, and how much attention are they attracting from New York home shoppers? (Getty Images)

Does the Winter Buzz Show Up in Searches?

"Winter getaway buzz hasn't translated into a winter surge in home shopping," says Realtor.com senior economist Hannah Jones.

"Interest in the Catskills and Beacon follows normal seasonal patterns, but both places hold on to the attention of New York–area shoppers better than most markets, and they're taking up a growing share of what those shoppers look at. At the same time, New York–area shoppers make up a smaller share of the audience for each destination than they did a year ago."

The seasonal pattern is predictable. Between the third and fourth quarters over the three years analyzed, NYC-metro listing views fell 21% to 25% in the Catskills and 19% to 25% in Dutchess County. Those drops tracked the national seasonal slowdown fairly closely.

Both markets did better against the broader field. NYC-area views across all listings fell 30% to 37% over the same stretch, so the Catskills and Dutchess captured a bigger share of attention heading into the holidays. In 2025, the Catskills' share of NYC-metro browsing rose from 1.03% in the third quarter to 1.23% in the fourth.

Winter is where the momentum fades. From the fourth quarter to the first, NYC-metro views fell 2%, 8%, and 15% in the Catskills across the three winters studied, and 6%, 5%, and 16% in Dutchess County. Over those same periods, NYC-metro views across all listings rose 2% to 10%.

For buyers picturing a winter retreat, that's the number to watch. Browsing in these towns cools after the holidays while New Yorkers' searches move elsewhere, so the buyers who keep looking through January and February are the ones showing real staying power.

Source: Kelsi Karruli · www.realtor.com