Market News

Home Sellers Weigh Price Cuts Against Mortgage Rate Buydowns

· 5 min read

With more sellers than buyers in the market, sellers are looking for ways to make their listings stand out. A mortgage rate buydown can direct a concession toward monthly affordability, which may matter more to a buyer than an equivalent price reduction.

More listings, fewer buyers

HousingWire Data puts the share of sellers cutting their asking prices at 43%, the highest level in four years. Redfin reported 63% more sellers than buyers in September. That imbalance gives buyers more room to negotiate, while mortgage rates continue to constrain what they can afford each month.

Price is often the first point of negotiation: buyers want both a sense of value and a lower payment. But a seller’s concession doesn’t have to take the form of a lower asking price. It could instead help reduce the buyer’s borrowing cost.

How a buydown changes the payment

A seller-funded rate buydown is paid at closing and covers some of the buyer’s interest cost, lowering the mortgage rate and payment. The structure determines how long the reduction lasts.

  • Temporary buydowns reduce the rate for an initial period, after which it returns to the full loan rate. Longer periods cost more. This structure may suit buyers who expect to refinance within that timeframe.

  • Permanent buydowns lower the rate over the life of the loan through discount points. One point costs 1% of the loan amount; FICO says each point generally reduces the rate by about a quarter of a percentage point. The lasting reduction may appeal to buyers planning to stay in the home for years.

Where the same concession can go further

Consider a seller willing to contribute $10,000 toward a buyer’s $420,000, 30-year fixed-rate mortgage at 7%. That money could fund a price reduction, a permanent buydown, or a 2-1 temporary buydown. The source’s comparison says the 2-1 option produces about eight times the monthly savings in the first year compared with the other approaches.

That difference matters because buyers often compare homes through the monthly payment. A lower payment at the outset may be more tangible than a modest reduction in the purchase price, though each buyer will value the options differently. A buydown can also give a listing a distinct incentive in a market where purchasers have alternatives.

The trade-off is that a temporary reduction expires, while a permanent one costs points upfront. A price cut, by comparison, changes the purchase price. The right use of a concession depends on the buyer’s priorities and the seller’s own numbers.

Planning the offer

  • Loan programs limit the amount sellers can contribute toward a buyer’s costs.

  • A buydown contribution doesn’t prevent a buyer from asking for repairs or other concessions.

  • Stating in the listing that a buydown is available can make buyers and their agents aware of the option.

  • An agent and the buyer’s lender can compare payment scenarios and other transaction costs before an offer arrives.

Lawrence Yun, chief economist at the National Association of Realtors, has said sellers need to account for local conditions, which may call for price discounts or other incentives to attract buyers. A rate buydown is one way to put that flexibility toward the buyer’s monthly budget.

For sellers weighing a concession, the useful comparison is the impact of each option on the buyer’s payment and on the seller’s proceeds. The numbers, worked through with an agent and lender, can show whether a buydown is likely to make the home more compelling than a price adjustment.


Get the KCM Blog
Members: Sign in now to set up your Personalized Posts & start sharing today!

Not a Member Yet? Click Here to learn more about KCM’s newest feature, Personalized Posts.

Source: KCM Crew · www.keepingcurrentmatters.com