For buyers seeking investment-grade tenants and long lease terms, the most relevant net lease inventory may be the inventory they can’t see. Nearly 5,800 net lease properties were listed for sale in the third quarter of 2026, yet fewer than 10 percent of available retail properties met those common quality criteria. That gap makes owner outreach a central part of acquisition work.
Many owners of strong, well-located properties haven’t chosen to sell. Since 2022, higher cap rates have cut into expected sale proceeds, prompting some owners to hold rather than list. Buyers who search only marketed properties therefore miss a substantial pool of potential opportunities.
Build the target list around the acquisition brief
Effective sourcing starts with precise requirements: tenant or industry, remaining lease term, rent escalations, geography, price range and property quality. These parameters help buyers focus outreach and avoid spending time on assets that won’t fit.
A search for one tenant in one metro might turn up only two listed properties, even though dozens of other locations meet the same criteria. Those properties can form a broader target list. The work then shifts to confirming lease details, identifying the decision maker and assessing whether the owner has a reason to consider an offer.
Property fit alone says little about sale timing. Ownership history can provide an opening: an owner who bought 15 or 20 years ago may have significant equity and new priorities, such as estate planning, portfolio diversification or a simpler set of holdings. A low tax basis can also make a sale harder to consider unless the owner has a clear plan for the proceeds.
Lease and debt events can change an owner’s calculus
Lease extensions may create a timely opportunity. An owner who has recently secured a longer term can sell with more income certainty, and the market tends to reflect that difference. In the third quarter, quick-service restaurant properties with 16 to 20 years remaining were priced below a 6 percent cap rate. Comparable properties with fewer than five years left on the lease were priced in the mid-7 percent range or higher.
Debt maturities may also prompt a decision. The Mortgage Bankers Association put 2026 commercial and multifamily mortgage maturities at $875 billion, about 17 percent of outstanding balances. Owners who borrowed when rates were much lower now face a choice among refinancing at a higher cost, adding equity or selling. With the Federal Reserve removing its expected 2026 rate cut, fewer owners may be willing to wait for borrowing costs to ease. A looming maturity doesn’t make a sale certain, but it gives buyers a reason to make contact.
Portfolio moves can matter as much as property-level events. An owner selling several assets, cutting exposure to a tenant or leaving a market may consider additional dispositions, even when a particular property isn’t being marketed. In that case, the potential seller’s motivation comes from the wider portfolio.
These signals help buyers prioritize calls, but only a conversation can establish an owner’s position. Some won’t sell; others may consider an offer without wanting a formal process, or may be planning a sale for the following year. Finding off-market properties takes sustained outreach.
Execution gives buyers credibility

An owner who hasn’t committed to selling is unlikely to spend time with a buyer whose financing is uncertain, diligence is open-ended or offer is far below market. Buyers build credibility with clear criteria, available equity, realistic pricing and a record of closing. Flexibility on timing can help too: an owner may value a reliable transaction schedule that fits other financial or personal plans.
Off-market access doesn’t automatically mean a discount. In the third quarter, top-tier assets such as McDonald’s and Chick-fil-A ground leases were priced as low as a 4.00 percent cap rate. The advantage for a buyer may be the chance to pursue a suitable property before broad marketing draws competing bidders. Any acquisition still calls for careful review of tenant credit, lease provisions, rent, location and residual value.
Databases can help identify owners, track transactions and assemble target lists. They can’t tell a buyer whether an owner will sell, what terms might work or whether the buyer can perform. That takes direct relationships, market knowledge and sound judgment.
As supply grows while high-quality inventory remains limited, competition is likely to begin before a property is listed. Lease events and debt maturities during the rest of 2026 may bring more owners to reassess their holdings. Buyers who pair a focused brief with steady outreach and credible execution will have a clearer path to properties that never reach listing services.
Randy Blankstein is president of net lease advisory firm The Boulder Group.
The post How to Uncover and Close Off-Market Net Lease Deals appeared first on Commercial Property Executive.